One of the reasons I’m so tired of debating Afghanistan — and, frankly, of blogging about it — is that bad ideas just don’t seem to go away. It’s like talking to a wall: “Let’s destroy the poppy fields.” “But it’s a bad idea.” “Yeah. Umm, let’s destroy the poppy fields.” Or how about the continuing obsession over tribal militias? Alex Strick van Linschoten calls it — quite generously, I think — “hope tactics”. What it actually reminds me of is this:
Afghanistan: The ‘These Go to Eleven’ School of Military Strategy
February 4, 2010 by Jari
Posted in Afghanistan | 6 Comments
6 Responses
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
-
Recently added
Jari on Twitter
- A pretty good who’s who of the #Syria battlefields by The Economist. economist.com/news/middle-ea… 20 hours ago
- RT @syrianews: The best thing you'll read on the Syrian rebel cannibal bit.ly/10yC2wH 1 day ago
- Syria: Brigade Fighting in Homs Implicated in Atrocities hrw.org/news/2013/05/1… 5 days ago
- News alert: A deadly cyclone is about to hit Arakan State where 10000s of Rohingya languish in makeshift camps. #Myanmar 5 days ago
- RT @Saad_Haroon: Doctors say #Imran #Khan is OK. Amazing! He is unstoppable. He should not run for Prime Minister, he should run for Optimu… 1 week ago
Old stuff
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- June 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
Categories
- Afghanistan (181)
- Al-Qaeda (21)
- AQI (6)
- Bangladesh (1)
- Burma (2)
- Caucasus (1)
- COIN (14)
- Election 08 (37)
- Human rights (25)
- India (6)
- Iran (14)
- Iraq (280)
- Iraq: Elections (29)
- ISF (16)
- Kurds (2)
- Lebanon (1)
- Libya (6)
- Media (26)
- Middle East (2)
- Militancy (16)
- Military (1)
- Misc (17)
- Mosul (16)
- Nuclear weapons (2)
- Pakistan (33)
- Shia (15)
- SOFA (14)
- Sri Lanka (7)
- Syria (1)
- Terrorism (24)
- U.S. (6)
- Uncategorized (1)
Comments
- John Spargo, first US neoconservative? | Dear Kitty. Some blog on The Wacky World of Markku Ruotsila, Finnish Neocon
- Julie on Message from Management
- B. Capra on The Pelton Controversy: Colouring the Facts in Afghanistan
- anan on Misrata: Setting the Record Straight on a Cemetery
- Martin Knutsen on Oslo: Those Who Cannot Be Blamed Can Be Blamed
Contact
jarzuli at gmail dot com
What’s a good idea, Jari? Leave the poppy fields in business? Frankly that crosses my thresholds to justify genocide. I just really can’t see the other point of view on that….
Elf,
Did you just compare allowing farmers to grow poppy to committing genocide? Because that’s how it reads. Umm, I really hope you didn’t mean that, because that’s kind of in violation of Godwin’s law and I don’t think you meant to violate that.
Love,
Josh
Josh,
Well than I must ask your forgiveness twice, first because I wasn’t comparing…so sorry for not being clear.
Secondly – because what I actually said was much worse. It places me where Godwin commands not to compare to…
Sorry. you put together the whole picture, it’s ugly people doing ugly things. Grow smack for a living on top of everything else and I really can’t see why we and the world should endure it.
Thank you,
Elf
Stupidest Man,
My name is Luke Larson, I’ve written a historical fiction novel based off my two tours to Ar Ramadi, Iraq as a Marine Corps Infantry Officer during the time of, “The Awakening.” My publication date is February 25th. I’m writing because I would be greatly honored if you would review the book on your blog.
To be specific I could either send you a selected section of chapters in a PDF, or if you send me a physical address I could send you an advance copy of the book.
I would greatly appreciate an honest, “No bullshit” review on the strengths and shortcomings of the book and its relevance to our current COIN conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan.
I look forward to hearing from you. Thanks you for your time and opinion.
Semper Fidelis,
Luke
http://www.lukeslarson.com
SENATOR’S SON: An Iraq War Novel (K.E., Inc; Publication date: February 25, 2010)
It also kind of resembles 7-minute abs
Good one!